Learning to Keep Your Balance

What if becoming the parent God has called you to be to your child from a hard place means that you need to un-learn as much or more than you need to learn? What if many of the popular approaches to parenting and discipline, many of which are regarded as “biblical,” actually aren’t best for your child given his background and history and what he needs to heal and grow? What if the parenting program you previously used, even with great success, when raising and training your other children needs to be significantly altered or even discarded for the child you adopted? What if the parenting techniques that most of your friends are using or that you grew up with are likely to be ineffective in achieving long-lasting change for the child you now love and desire to connect with?

I believe that parents need to seriously consider these and many similar questions as they set the course for how to best relate to and parent children from hard places. More importantly, parents need to honestly engage the question, “Am I willing to unlearn and let go of certain ways of parenting?” If you’re willing, what “new things” do you need to learn and, most importantly, how do you go about doing this?

We have come to conclude that many traditional parenting approaches and programs, including many promoted in our churches, are simply not effective for children from hard places. Many of these approaches often tend toward the extremes, while also failing to reflect the heart of God for our children. They are either overly harsh, punitive and authoritarian in nature (referred to in the child development literature as “Authoritarian Parenting”) or overly permissive, excusing and lacking a healthy amount of structure (referred to as “Permissive Parenting”). Tragically, parenting styles falling within either of these extremes often serve to compound the problems they intend to address, while leaving parents and children more frustrated, disconnected and discontent.

As we mentioned, many parents are inclined toward Authoritarian Parenting or a “law and order” approach, focusing almost exclusively on structure—rules, requirements, control, consequences and punishment. Misbehavior is met with more and more structure, with a focus on changing the behavior above all else. With this high structure, low nurture approach, every offense is met with a consequence or punishment, and as the behaviors persist or escalate so too does the punishment.

Yet both research and experience show this approach is almost certain to fail with at-risk children. Because many of our children lack a solid foundation of trust, which ideally would’ve been established in the first year of life, attempts to establish authority (i.e., “who’s the boss”) without connection generally prove ineffective. Ironically, research indicates this reality persists even as children grow older, evidenced, for example, by the fact that children from homes with an emphasis on structure without a corresponding emphasis on nurture are more likely to engage in hard drug use and other acting out behaviors as teens.

Conversely, other parents practice Permissive Parenting by focusing almost exclusively on nurture, ignoring altogether their child’s need for structure to learn to regulate his behavior and develop healthy relationships. In their desire to be compassionate and extend grace to their child, these parents sacrifice the structure their child needs. This is seen in a parent who allows her child to behave in hurtful and even cruel ways because, as she said, “he has already been through so much I simply want to show him God’s love and grace.” One mother told us she allowed her daughter to repeatedly attack her, bruising her face and body, and accepted the beatings believing she was showing her God’s love. Instead of helping their child heal and grow, however, these parents are offering “cheap grace” by allowing their child to operate without boundaries, guidance and correction. As a result, this approach also fails to bring about the lasting change parents desire, just as it does in our lives when we cheapen the grace God extends to us.

Instead, we are convinced that parents need to find a new balance in their approach to parenting, referred to as an Authoritative Parenting style. Particularly for children with difficult and painful histories, parents need to apply this balance in order to truly connect with their children and lead them toward healing and lasting connections. This balance isn’t found so much in mastering the “right” parenting program (be it “Christian” or otherwise) as it is in understanding and applying the principles of Paul’s instructions in Ephesians 6:4 to “take our children by the hand and lead them in the way of the Master” (The Message). Different translations and versions of Scripture use slightly different terms to communicate this point (including “nurture and admonition,” “discipline and instruction,” and “training and instruction”) but the essential idea remains: as parents we are responsible for connecting with and correcting our children in a way that shows them the love of Jesus. It is in providing a consistent balance comprised of equal parts of high nurture (connecting) and high structure (correcting) that we can best lead our children in the direction they need to go and show them the love of God in tangible ways.

This conclusion is also supported by child development research that confirms that an optimal environment for children is one in which there is an equal balance between nurture and structure. This Authoritative Parenting style is rooted in the belief that the Law (structure) is our teacher and that Grace (nurture) is our guide. In fact, the research supports that those children who experience this ideal balance are at a lower risk for acting out behaviors in adolescence. The parent who understands the need for a balance of nurture and structure is most likely to be successful with the at-risk child.

I like to think of this as yet another example of science catching up with God. After all, isn’t this how God relates to us as His children? Using a balance of both nurture (His tender mercies) and structure (His guiding hand that directs and corrects us), He kindly, yet firmly, leads us into a right relationship with Him. The apostle Paul puts it this way: “God is kind, but he’s not soft. In kindness he takes us firmly by the hand and leads us into a radical life-change” (Romans 2:4, The Message). Both we and our children need love that is expressed in ways that lead to connection and transformation.

*This article is an excerpt from Chapter 6 of Created To Connect: A Christian’s Guide to The Connected Child. This study guide companion to The Connected Child can be downloaded for free. Printed copies of the study guide are also available for purchase.

Address Book Address Card adjust Air Freshener align-center align-justify align-left align-right Allergies ambulance American Sign Language Interpreting Anchor Angle Double Down Angle Double Left Angle Double Right Angle Double Up angle-down angle-left angle-right angle-up Angry Face Ankh Fruit Apple Archive Archway Alternate Arrow Circle Down Alternate Arrow Circle Left Alternate Arrow Circle Right Alternate Arrow Circle Up Arrow Circle Down Arrow Circle Left Arrow Circle Right Arrow Circle Up arrow-down arrow-left arrow-right arrow-up Alternate Arrows Alternate Arrows Horizontal Alternate Arrows Vertical Assistive Listening Systems asterisk At Atlas Atom Audio Description Award Baby Baby Carriage Backspace backward Balance Scale ban Band-Aid barcode Bars Baseball Ball Basketball Ball Bath Battery Empty Battery Full Battery 1/2 Full Battery 1/4 Full Battery 3/4 Full Bed beer bell Bell Slash Bezier Curve Bible Bicycle Binoculars Biohazard Birthday Cake Blender Blender Phone Blind Blog bold Lightning Bolt Bomb Bone Bong book Book of the Dead Book Open Book Reader bookmark Bowling Ball Box Box Open Boxes Braille Brain Briefcase Medical Briefcase Broadcast Tower Broom Brush Bug Building bullhorn Bullseye Burn Bus Bus Alt Business Time Calculator Calendar Alternate Calendar Calendar Check Calendar with Day Focus Calendar Minus Calendar Plus Calendar Times Calendar with Week Focus camera Retro Camera Campground Candy Cane Cannabis Capsules Car Alternate Car Car Battery Car Crash Car Side Caret Down Caret Left Caret Right Caret Square Down Caret Square Left Caret Square Right Caret Square Up Caret Up Carrot Shopping Cart Arrow Down Add to Shopping Cart Cash Register Cat certificate Chair Chalkboard Chalkboard Teacher Charging Station Area Chart Bar Chart Line Chart Pie Chart Check Check Circle Check Double Check Square Chess Chess Bishop Chess Board Chess King Chess Knight Chess Pawn Chess Queen Chess Rook Chevron Circle Down Chevron Circle Left Chevron Circle Right Chevron Circle Up chevron-down chevron-left chevron-right chevron-up Child Church Circle Circle Notched City Clipboard Clipboard with Check Clipboard List Clock Clone Closed Captioning Cloud Alternate Cloud Download Cloud with (a chance of) Meatball Cloud with Moon Cloud with Moon and Rain Cloud with Rain Cloud with Heavy Showers Cloud with Sun Cloud with Sun and Rain Alternate Cloud Upload Cocktail Code Code Branch Coffee cog cogs Coins Columns comment Alternate Comment Comment Dollar Comment Dots Comment Slash comments Comments Dollar Compact Disc Compass Compress Alternate Compress Arrows Concierge Bell Cookie Cookie Bite Copy Copyright Couch Credit Card crop Alternate Crop Cross Crosshairs Crow Crown Cube Cubes Cut Database Deaf Democrat Desktop Dharmachakra Diagnoses Dice Dice D20 Dice D6 Dice Five Dice Four Dice One Dice Six Dice Three Dice Two Digital Tachograph Directions Divide Dizzy Face DNA Dog Dollar Sign Dolly Dolly Flatbed Door Closed Door Open Dot Circle Dove Download Drafting Compass Dragon Draw Polygon Drum Drum Steelpan Drumstick with Bite Taken Out Dumbbell Dumpster Dumpster Fire Dungeon Edit eject Horizontal Ellipsis Vertical Ellipsis Envelope Envelope Open Envelope Open-text Envelope Square Equals eraser Ethernet Euro Sign Alternate Exchange exclamation Exclamation Circle Exclamation Triangle Expand Alternate Expand Arrows Alternate External Link Alternate External Link Square Eye Eye Dropper Eye Slash fast-backward fast-forward Fax Feather Alternate Feather Female fighter-jet File Alternate File Archive File Audio File Code File File Contract File CSV File Download Excel File File Export Image File File Import File Invoice File Invoice with US Dollar Medical File Alternate Medical File PDF File Powerpoint File File Prescription File Signature File Upload Video File Word File Fill Fill Drip Film Filter Fingerprint fire Alternate Fire fire-extinguisher First Aid Fish Raised Fist flag flag-checkered United States of America Flag Flask Flushed Face Folder Folder Minus Folder Open Folder Plus font Font Awesome Full Logo Football Ball forward Frog Frowning Face Frowning Face With Open Mouth Funnel Dollar Futbol Gamepad Gas Pump Gavel Gem Genderless Ghost gift Gifts Glass Cheers Martini Glass Alternate Glass Martini Glass Whiskey Glasses Globe Globe with Africa shown Globe with Americas shown Globe with Asia shown Globe with Europe shown Golf Ball Gopuram Graduation Cap Greater Than Greater Than Equal To Grimacing Face Grinning Face Alternate Grinning Face Grinning Face With Smiling Eyes Grinning Face With Sweat Smiling Face With Heart-Eyes Grinning Squinting Face Rolling on the Floor Laughing Star-Struck Face With Tears of Joy Face With Tongue Squinting Face With Tongue Winking Face With Tongue Grinning Winking Face Grip Horizontal Grip Lines Grip Lines Vertical Grip Vertical Guitar H Square Hammer Hamsa Hand Holding Hand Holding Heart Hand Holding US Dollar Lizard (Hand) Paper (Hand) Peace (Hand) Hand Pointing Down Hand Pointing Left Hand Pointing Right Hand Pointing Up Pointer (Hand) Rock (Hand) Scissors (Hand) Spock (Hand) Hands Helping Hands Handshake Hanukiah Hashtag Wizard's Hat Haykal HDD heading headphones Alternate Headphones Headset Heart Heart Broken Heartbeat Helicopter Highlighter Hiking Hippo History Hockey Puck Holly Berry home Horse Horse Head hospital Alternate Hospital Hospital Symbol Hot Tub Hotel Hourglass Hourglass End Hourglass Half Hourglass Start Damaged House Hryvnia I Beam Cursor Icicles Identification Badge Identification Card Alternate Identification Card Igloo Image Images inbox Indent Industry Infinity Info Info Circle italic Jedi Joint Journal of the Whills Kaaba key Keyboard Khanda Kissing Face Kissing Face With Smiling Eyes Face Blowing a Kiss Kiwi Bird Landmark Language Laptop Laptop Code Grinning Face With Big Eyes Laugh Face with Beaming Eyes Laughing Squinting Face Laughing Winking Face Layer Group leaf Lemon Less Than Less Than Equal To Alternate Level Down Alternate Level Up Life Ring Lightbulb Link Turkish Lira Sign List Alternate List list-ol list-ul location-arrow lock Lock Open Alternate Long Arrow Down Alternate Long Arrow Left Alternate Long Arrow Right Alternate Long Arrow Up Low Vision Luggage Cart magic magnet Mail Bulk Male Map Map Marked Alternate Map Marked map-marker Alternate Map Marker Map Pin Map Signs Marker Mars Mars Double Mars Stroke Mars Stroke Horizontal Mars Stroke Vertical Mask Medal medkit Neutral Face Face Without Mouth Face With Rolling Eyes Memory Menorah Mercury Meteor Microchip microphone Alternate Microphone Alternate Microphone Slash Microphone Slash Microscope minus Minus Circle Minus Square Mitten Mobile Phone Alternate Mobile Money Bill Alternate Money Bill Wavy Money Bill Alternate Wavy Money Bill Money Check Alternate Money Check Monument Moon Mortar Pestle Mosque Motorcycle Mountain Mouse Pointer Mug Hot Music Wired Network Neuter Newspaper Not Equal Medical Notes Object Group Object Ungroup Oil Can Om Otter Outdent Paint Brush Paint Roller Palette Pallet Paper Plane Paperclip Parachute Box paragraph Parking Passport Pastafarianism Paste pause Pause Circle Paw Peace Pen Alternate Pen Pen Fancy Pen Nib Pen Square Alternate Pencil Pencil Ruler People Carry Percent Percentage Person Entering Booth Phone Phone Slash Phone Square Phone Volume Piggy Bank Pills Place of Worship plane Plane Arrival Plane Departure play Play Circle Plug plus Plus Circle Plus Square Podcast Poll Poll H Poo Poo Storm Poop Portrait Pound Sign Power Off Pray Praying Hands Prescription Prescription Bottle Alternate Prescription Bottle print Procedures Project Diagram Puzzle Piece qrcode Question Question Circle Quidditch quote-left quote-right Quran Radiation Alternate Radiation Rainbow random Receipt Recycle Redo Alternate Redo Registered Trademark Reply reply-all Republican Restroom Retweet Ribbon Ring road Robot rocket Route rss RSS Square Ruble Sign Ruler Ruler Combined Ruler Horizontal Ruler Vertical Running Indian Rupee Sign Crying Face Loudly Crying Face Satellite Satellite Dish Save School Screwdriver Scroll Sd Card Search Search Dollar Search Location Search Minus Search Plus Seedling Server Shapes Share Alternate Share Alternate Share Square Share Square Shekel Sign Alternate Shield Ship Shipping Fast Shoe Prints Shopping Bag Shopping Basket shopping-cart Shower Shuttle Van Sign Alternate Sign In Sign Language Alternate Sign Out signal Signature SIM Card Sitemap Skating Skiing Skiing Nordic Skull Skull & Crossbones Slash Sleigh Horizontal Sliders Smiling Face Beaming Face With Smiling Eyes Winking Face Smog Smoking Smoking Ban SMS Snowboarding Snowflake Snowman Snowplow Socks Solar Panel Sort Sort Alpha Down Sort Alpha Up Sort Amount Down Sort Amount Up Sort Down (Descending) Sort Numeric Down Sort Numeric Up Sort Up (Ascending) Spa Space Shuttle Spider Spinner Splotch Spray Can Square Square Full Alternate Square Root Stamp Star Star and Crescent star-half Alternate Star Half Star of David Star of Life step-backward step-forward Stethoscope Sticky Note stop Stop Circle Stopwatch Store Alternate Store Stream Street View Strikethrough Stroopwafel subscript Subway Suitcase Suitcase Rolling Sun superscript Hushed Face Swatchbook Swimmer Swimming Pool Synagogue Sync Alternate Sync Syringe table Table Tennis tablet Alternate Tablet Tablets Alternate Tachometer tag tags Tape Tasks Taxi Teeth Teeth Open High Temperature Low Temperature Tenge Terminal text-height text-width th th-large th-list Theater Masks Thermometer Thermometer Empty Thermometer Full Thermometer 1/2 Full Thermometer 1/4 Full Thermometer 3/4 Full thumbs-down thumbs-up Thumbtack Alternate Ticket Times Times Circle tint Tint Slash Tired Face Toggle Off Toggle On Toilet Toilet Paper Toolbox Tools Tooth Torah Torii Gate Tractor Trademark Traffic Light Train Tram Transgender Alternate Transgender Trash Alternate Trash Tree trophy truck Truck Loading Truck Monster Truck Moving Truck Side T-Shirt TTY Television Umbrella Umbrella Beach Underline Undo Alternate Undo Universal Access University unlink unlock Alternate Unlock Upload User Alternate User Alternate User Slash User Astronaut User Check User Circle User Clock User Cog User Edit User Friends User Graduate User Injured User Lock user-md User Minus User Ninja User Plus User Secret User Shield User Slash User Tag User Tie Remove User Users Users Cog Utensil Spoon Utensils Vector Square Venus Venus Double Venus Mars Vial Vials Video Video Slash Vihara Volleyball Ball Volume Down Volume Mute Volume Off Volume Up Vote Yea Cardboard VR Walking Wallet Warehouse Water Weight Hanging Weight Wheelchair WiFi Wind Window Close Window Maximize Window Minimize Window Restore Wine Bottle Wine Glass Alternate Wine Glas Won Sign Wrench X-Ray Yen Sign Yin Yang 500px Accessible Icon Accusoft Acquisitions Incorporated App.net Adobe Adversal affiliatetheme Algolia Alipay Amazon Amazon Pay Amilia Android AngelList Angry Creative Angular App Store iOS App Store Apper Systems AB Apple Apple Pay Artstation Asymmetrik, Ltd. Atlassian Audible Autoprefixer avianex Aviato Amazon Web Services (AWS) Bandcamp Behance Behance Square BIMobject Bitbucket Bitcoin Bity Font Awesome Black Tie BlackBerry Blogger Blogger B Bluetooth Bluetooth BTC Büromöbel-Experte GmbH & Co. KG. BuySellAds Canadian Maple Leaf Amazon Pay Credit Card American Express Credit Card Apple Pay Credit Card Diner's Club Credit Card Discover Credit Card JCB Credit Card MasterCard Credit Card Paypal Credit Card Stripe Credit Card Visa Credit Card Centercode Centos Chrome cloudscale.ch Cloudsmith cloudversify Codepen Codie Pie Confluence Connect Develop Contao cPanel Creative Commons Creative Commons Attribution Creative Commons Noncommercial Creative Commons Noncommercial (Euro Sign) Creative Commons Noncommercial (Yen Sign) Creative Commons No Derivative Works Creative Commons Public Domain Alternate Creative Commons Public Domain Creative Commons Remix Creative Commons Share Alike Creative Commons Sampling Creative Commons Sampling + Creative Commons Share Creative Commons CC0 Critical Role CSS 3 Logo Alternate CSS3 Logo Cuttlefish Dungeons & Dragons D&D Beyond DashCube Delicious Logo deploy.dog Deskpro DEV deviantART DHL Diaspora Digg Logo Digital Ocean Discord Discourse DocHub Docker Draft2digital Dribbble Dribbble Square Dropbox Drupal Logo Dyalog Earlybirds eBay Edge Browser Elementor Ello Ember Galactic Empire Envira Gallery Erlang Ethereum Etsy ExpeditedSSL Facebook Facebook F Facebook Messenger Facebook Square Fantasy Flight-games FedEx Fedora Figma Firefox First Order Alternate First Order firstdraft Flickr Flipboard Fly Font Awesome Alternate Font Awesome Font Awesome Flag Font Awesome Full Logo Fonticons Fonticons Fi Fort Awesome Alternate Fort Awesome Forumbee Foursquare Free Code Camp FreeBSD Fulcrum Galactic Republic Galactic Senate Get Pocket GG Currency GG Currency Circle Git Git Square GitHub Alternate GitHub GitHub Square GitKraken GitLab Gitter Glide Glide G Gofore Goodreads Goodreads G Google Logo Google Drive Google Play Google Plus Google Plus G Google Plus Square Google Wallet Gratipay (Gittip) Grav Gripfire, Inc. Grunt Gulp Hacker News Hacker News Square Hackerrank Hips HireAHelper Hooli Hornbill Hotjar Houzz HTML 5 Logo HubSpot IMDB Instagram Intercom Internet-explorer InVision ioxhost iTunes Itunes Note Java Jedi Order Jenkis Jira Joget Joomla Logo JavaScript (JS) JavaScript (JS) Square jsFiddle Kaggle Keybase KeyCDN Kickstarter Kickstarter K KORVUE Laravel last.fm last.fm Square Leanpub Less Line LinkedIn LinkedIn In Linode Linux lyft Magento Mailchimp Mandalorian Markdown Mastodon MaxCDN MedApps Medium Medium M MRT Meetup Megaport Mendeley Microsoft Mix Mixcloud Mizuni MODX Monero Napster Neos Nimblr Nintendo Switch Node.js Node.js JS npm NS8 Nutritionix Odnoklassniki Odnoklassniki Square Old Republic OpenCart OpenID Opera Optin Monster Open Source Initiative page4 Corporation Pagelines Palfed Patreon Paypal Penny Arcade Periscope Phabricator Phoenix Framework Phoenix Squadron PHP Pied Piper Logo Alternate Pied Piper Logo Pied Piper-hat Pied Piper PP Logo (Old) Pinterest Pinterest P Pinterest Square PlayStation Product Hunt Pushed Python QQ QuinScape Quora R Project Raspberry Pi Ravelry React ReactEurope ReadMe Rebel Alliance red river reddit Logo reddit Alien reddit Square Redhat Renren replyd Researchgate Resolving Rev.io Rocket.Chat